Morgan Tocker (mtocker) wrote,
Morgan Tocker
mtocker

On Testing MySQL Knowledge

I can't read posts like this one without at least a little chuckle. Is the number one question you should be asking people how to start and stop MySQL on Windows? How does that really demonstrate how good someone is at their job when most people deploy on Linux[1]?

The original MySQL certification for 4.1 used to ask a whole bunch of trivia exactly like this - my favourite was a question where you had to say if a particular subqueries caused a syntax error. I don't know how this tests skill, since most subqueries shouldn't be used in production (hint: they are unoptimized in MySQL).

But MySQL changed its certification format: the new exams are Performanced-Based. This means to pass, you have to solve some of the problems you will be doing in real life. Hats off to Dave for leading this initiative.

Technical interviews need to change just as MySQL has. They should be organized in a way that doesn't intimidate the candidate who might know what they are doing, but can't always express it words when under pressure. Silly questions and 'gut feelings' about responses tend to favour the over confident.

I had a hand in designing the interview process at Percona. One of the steps candidates go through is a challenge to be completed on two running EC2 instances. I don't think it's flawless, but you tell me what is likely to be a better indication of talent:

Test #1:
* What does tee command do in MySQL?
* What is a serial data type in MySQL?
* If I created a column with data type VARCHAR(3), what would I expect to see in MySQL table?

Test #2:
* Log into these two servers (xxx is the master, yyy is the slave).
* Tell me if you think there is a replication problem.
* Resync the slave using the lowest impact method possible if there is.
* Optimize these two queries while you are at it.

Test #2 isn't the actual test we use, but it's not far off.

I know a lot of DBAs that probably can't answer test #1 correctly. Does this mean they are bad at their job? That is one possibility, but the more likely is that this test is useless and should only come out on Pub Trivia night.

[1] On an unrelated note, the example answers for questions 3, 11, 12, 14, 15, 22 also demonstrate a misunderstanding ranging from small to just fundamentally wrong.
Tags: mysql
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 6 comments